NYC Mayor defends Daniel Penny

New York City Mayor Eric Adams has come out in defense of Marine veteran Daniel Penny, who is currently facing charges in the death of Jordan Neely, a homeless man with a lengthy criminal history. Neely, who had a history of mental illness and an active arrest warrant at the time of his death, shouted death threats in a subway car before he was subdued and choked out by Penny.

Penny, 26, is facing a manslaughter charge and criminally negligent homicide charge in connection with Neely’s death. The trial began in May 2023, and jurors are currently deliberating on the case.

Adams spoke out in support of Penny, stating that he believes Penny was responding appropriately to a dangerous situation on the subway. Neely had entered the train, throwing his jacket on the ground and making death threats, prompting fear among passengers.

Penny took action by grabbing Neely from behind in a headlock and holding him down with the help of another passenger. He remained at the scene and cooperated with police. Penny’s defense attorney, Steven Raiser, argued that Penny only applied pressure when necessary to restrain Neely, who was known for his erratic behavior.

Adams criticized the city’s mental health system, pointing out the failure to provide adequate support for individuals like Neely who struggle with mental illness. He also addressed the media’s portrayal of Neely, expressing concern that the coverage painted him as a “young innocent child” rather than acknowledging his criminal history and violent behavior.

The City Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Neely’s death a homicide by asphyxiation, attributing it to the chokehold applied by Penny. Neely had a history of violent incidents, including attacks on subway riders and other criminal behavior.

Despite the prosecution’s arguments that Penny saw Neely as a threat to be eliminated, Adams stood by his defense of the Marine veteran. He emphasized that Penny was acting in response to a dangerous situation and should not be blamed for the lack of police presence on the subway.

As the trial continues, the outcome remains uncertain. However, Adams’ vocal support for Penny highlights the complexities of the case and the challenges faced by individuals who find themselves in similar situations. The mayor’s remarks serve as a reminder of the importance of considering all factors in cases involving self-defense and public safety.