Hard Truths is a horror movie
Recently, I had the opportunity to ask a group of film enthusiasts a thought-provoking question: what’s a movie that you absolutely loved but never want to watch again? The responses I received were quite expected, with titles like Requiem for a Dream, Come and See, and Midsommar being mentioned. These films are known for delving deep into the darker aspects of human cruelty and suffering, leaving viewers feeling drained and uncomfortable, with no desire to revisit the experience.
However, a new addition to the list of movies that fit this criteria is Hard Truths, the latest offering from writer-director Mike Leigh. Unlike the aforementioned films, Hard Truths doesn’t feature war crimes or gruesome scenes. Instead, it presents an intimate and poignant portrayal of a Black family struggling to cope with the challenges of life in London.
The film follows the lives of various family members, including Moses, the reclusive adult son with hidden passions and suppressed anger, and Curtley, the father who finds solace in his work. At the center of it all is Pansy, the matriarch of the family, portrayed brilliantly by Marianne Jean-Baptiste. Pansy is a complex character, filled with bitterness and resentment, constantly complaining about her circumstances and lashing out at those around her.
Jean-Baptiste’s performance as Pansy is nothing short of remarkable, capturing the character’s inner turmoil and struggles with authenticity and depth. Through her portrayal, we see a woman trapped in a cycle of self-destructive behavior, unable to break free from her own patterns of negativity and despair.
The film’s focus on Pansy’s character is where its strength lies, offering a nuanced and unflinching look at the effects of emotional trauma and mental health struggles. Leigh handles the subject matter with care and sensitivity, neither excusing nor condemning Pansy’s actions but simply showing the devastating impact they have on her family and herself.
In addition to its powerful character study, Hard Truths also explores themes of race and identity, with the majority of the cast members being Black. Leigh’s decision to involve the actors in the development of the film’s dialogue and specifics adds a layer of authenticity to the storytelling, deflecting accusations of appropriation and ensuring that the film remains true to the experiences of its characters.
Ultimately, Hard Truths is a raw and unflinching portrayal of human suffering and resilience, showcasing the universal truths that connect us all, regardless of race or background. While the film may not be an easy watch, its profound insights into the human condition make it a compelling and thought-provoking piece of cinema that is sure to leave a lasting impact on viewers.
