Israeli security experts argue ‘bad deal’ with Hamas but ‘no other way’ to free hostages
After 15 months of brutal conflict, the news that Israel and Hamas have finally signed a deal was met with an international sigh of relief on Friday. This deal could mean the return of all remaining hostages who have long been held in unconscionable conditions, as well as bring an end to the bloodshed in Gaza.
The first phase of the ceasefire and hostage-exchange agreement will begin on Sunday, with the return of three of the 33 hostages slated to be released to Israel. The remaining 65 hostages, both dead and alive, will be negotiated for on the 16th day of the ceasefire, with their return set for the 43rd day of the deal.
While the deal has been approved by the Israeli cabinet, there are mixed feelings among the families of hostages still in Gaza. Retired Israel Defense Forces (IDF) Major General Yaakov Amidror acknowledged that the deal is not perfect but stressed the moral imperative of securing the release of the hostages.
Amidror highlighted objections to the deal, with some arguing that all hostages should have been included in the first phase and others expressing concerns about Israel’s security. Details on the IDF’s withdrawal from Gaza remain unclear, with reports suggesting they will remain until the last hostage is freed.
Despite some opposition to the deal, polls show that the majority of Israelis support the return of the hostages over completely destroying Hamas. Former National Security Advisor John Hannah described the decision as tortuous but necessary for the Israeli people.
The agreement marks a difficult compromise, with Israel prioritizing the return of the hostages while Hamas is able to claim survival. The hope is that this deal will bring an end to the conflict and pave the way for a more peaceful future in the region.
As the ceasefire takes effect, the international community watches with cautious optimism, hoping that this deal will lead to lasting peace and reconciliation between Israel and Hamas.
