Decision to refill Lake Pisiquid coming with side-effects, say some Windsor residents

Residents in Windsor, N.S., have been divided over the decision to close the gates of an aboiteau and keep Lake Pisiquid filled with water for the past two years. The controversy stems from a Department of Fisheries and Oceans order to restore the Avon River to a natural state and allow fish to pass through. However, in June 2023, a state of emergency was declared by the province, ordering the gates to remain closed to maximize water supply for firefighting efforts during wildfires in the area.

Some residents, like fisherman Darren Porter, believe that the decision to keep the gates closed is unnecessary and causing more issues than it’s solving. Porter, who is part of scientific teams conducting work on the river, argues that the need for a dry hydrant in downtown Windsor is no longer logical, as there is now a river boat ramp extending to the water. He questions the province’s reasoning behind the emergency order and its impact on the community.

On the other hand, the Municipality of West Hants is planning for a future with or without the water from Lake Pisiquid. CAO Mark Phillips stated that the municipality is building a water storage tank and combining the former water utilities of Windsor and Falmouth to accommodate the growing population and improve firefighting capabilities. Phillips acknowledges the importance of having water in the lake for firefighting purposes but is also preparing for a scenario where the gates remain closed.

However, some residents, like David Hunter, are growing impatient with the ongoing situation. Hunter, who owns an antique shop on the Windsor waterfront, is concerned about the safety risks posed by unfinished work on Highway 101, which cannot be completed until a new aboiteau design is approved. He calls for a resolution to the issue, whether it means opening the gates or finding an alternative solution.

Another resident, Amanda Dunfield, believes that the province’s decision to close the gates is contributing to sewage issues in the community. Dunfield, who has experienced multiple flooding incidents in her home, attributes the problem partly to the water levels at Lake Pisiquid. She has filed a lawsuit against the Municipality of West Hants for negligence and nuisance, claiming that the stormwater system is not adequately designed to handle high lake levels.

In response to these concerns, the Emergency Management Department defended the decision to keep the gates closed, stating that water tankers would not be sufficient in the event of a wildfire. The department emphasized the need for adequate water supply for firefighting efforts and highlighted the shortcomings of the current municipal system in handling large wildfires.

As the debate over the aboiteau gates continues, residents are looking for a resolution that addresses both the safety concerns and the environmental impact of keeping Lake Pisiquid filled with water. The community is divided on the issue, with some advocating for the gates to be opened while others support the province’s decision to prioritize water supply for firefighting. Ultimately, finding a balanced solution that meets the needs of all stakeholders is crucial for the future of Windsor and its residents.