NJ DEI law at odds with Trump’s order, Republicans pushing repeal effort say
Two New Jersey lawmakers, Assembs. Gregory McGuckin and Paul Kanitra, are pushing for schools to adhere to President Donald Trump’s executive order to eliminate what they call “radical indoctrination” in K-12 education. They have introduced bill A-5560, which aims to repeal a 2021 state law mandating instruction on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) topics such as unconscious bias, gender identity tolerance, and disability tolerance.
McGuckin and Kanitra argue that DEI teachings are not suitable for children’s education, describing them as a rebranded form of Marxist ideology that undermines merit-based rewards and excellence. They believe that true diversity, equity, and inclusion should promote free associations that foster innovation and progress. Kanitra expressed disbelief in the notion that a student’s skin color determines their success or failure, labeling such teachings as misguided and harmful.
Both lawmakers pointed to a decline in education quality and test scores following the COVID-related school closures ordered by Gov. Phil Murphy. They emphasized that students have not yet returned to pre-pandemic proficiency levels, attributing this setback to what they see as ineffective teaching methods.
On the other hand, New Jersey’s Democratic Attorney General, Matthew J. Platkin, remains committed to upholding DEI curricula in schools despite Trump’s order. Platkin defended the state’s diverse educational system, stating that it has thrived by embracing the state’s multiculturalism. He vowed to continue fighting against any federal attempts to restrict funding or educational opportunities for students.
Platkin’s stance was supported by New York Attorney General Letitia James, who rejected the notion that diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts can be banned through executive orders. New Jersey’s DEI law, championed by former Gov. Richard Codey, mandates school districts to incorporate teachings on diversity, equity, inclusion, tolerance, and belonging starting in 2021.
The bill emphasizes the importance of addressing unconscious bias, economic disparities, and creating safe, inclusive environments for all students. Assemb. Carol Murphy highlighted the necessity of ensuring that students are accepting and understanding of each other’s experiences without attaching stigma based on culture, race, sexuality, or other factors.
The repeal effort has gained additional support from Republican lawmakers, including Assembs. Gregory Myhre, Brian Rumpf, and Erik Peterson. The debate over DEI in schools continues to be a point of contention between political parties in New Jersey, with differing views on the impact and necessity of such teachings.
In conclusion, the discussion on DEI in education reflects broader debates on ideology, curriculum, and the role of government in shaping educational policies. As lawmakers navigate these complex issues, the focus remains on providing a quality and inclusive education for all students in New Jersey.
