Which ‘next’ is Danielle Smith’s Ottawa-affairs panel steering Alberta toward?

Albertans are gearing up to participate in the Alberta Next feedback project, led by Premier Danielle Smith, which aims to explore the possibility of the province exiting the Canada Pension Plan. Before they can weigh in on this important decision, residents are required to watch a five-minute video that highlights the potential benefits of such a move.

The video pitches the idea of a provincial pension plan by emphasizing lower premiums, higher benefits, and a provincially led investment strategy that avoids ideological decision-making. However, it also acknowledges potential downsides, such as unclear exit rules in federal legislation and concerns about Ottawa’s anti-Alberta stance.

After watching the video, respondents are asked multiple-choice questions, including whether the province should start its own pension plan. This initiative is reminiscent of the Fair Deal Panel launched by Premier Jason Kenney in 2019, which explored the viability of an Alberta-only pension and police force, among other issues.

One key difference in the Alberta Next project is Premier Smith’s direct involvement as chair, which could increase interest in upcoming town halls. However, some attendees may want to address other pressing matters, as evidenced by a recent heated meeting on coal mining.

The government’s approach to gathering public opinion has raised concerns among experts like political scientist Jared Wesley. He believes that rather than genuinely collecting feedback, the government is attempting to shape public opinion by presenting biased information. The loaded language in the videos and surveys, which frequently mention the federal government’s Liberal affiliation, skews the narrative.

The proposed changes under the Alberta Next project, including creating a new police force, pension fund, or tax-collecting body, come with significant costs and logistical challenges. Implementing these reforms would require substantial financial resources and buy-in from Ottawa and other provinces.

Furthermore, some proposals, like withholding public services from certain classes of immigrants, could have negative repercussions and fuel social divisions. It’s essential for the government to consider the potential consequences of its actions and ensure that any reforms are grounded in reality.

As Albertans prepare to participate in the Alberta Next project and potentially shape the province’s future, it’s crucial for them to critically assess the information presented and consider the broader implications of these proposed changes. By engaging in informed discussions and advocating for realistic solutions, residents can contribute to a more transparent and effective decision-making process.