Accuracy of ‘Conclave’, Oscar-winning film, according to international theologian

The 2025 Oscar-nominated film “Conclave” directed by Edward Berger, starring Ralph Fiennes, Isabella Rossellini, and Stanley Tucci, brought the political and religious traditions of electing a new pope to life. The film resonated deeply with viewers as it coincided with the declining health of Pope Francis, who passed away on April 21, 2025, just after Easter Sunday.

Based on the novel by Robert Harris, the film follows the process of Catholic cardinals gathering to elect a new pope. Despite some creative liberties taken in the film, Dennis Doyle, a professor emeritus at the University of Dayton, found it to be fairly accurate in its portrayal of the conclave proceedings. Doyle, who taught at the Catholic research university for 40 years, praised the film for its sympathetic portrayal of the characters and attention to detail.

While some Catholics criticized the film as anti-Catholic and dishonest, Doyle believed that it raised important questions about the role of women in the church. The film’s depiction of women serving as nuns to the cardinals sparked a conversation about gender equality within the Catholic Church.

The controversial ending of the film, which sees an intersex character elected as pope, was seen as symbolic by Doyle. He acknowledged that while the scenario was far-fetched, it raised important questions about gender and leadership within the church.

Following Pope Francis’ death, “Conclave” is expected to generate interest in the Catholic Church. Despite the film’s fictional elements, it sheds light on the politicking that occurs during the papal conclave and highlights the intrigue surrounding the election of a new pope.

“Conclave” was nominated for several Academy Awards in 2025, ultimately winning for Best Adapted Screenplay. The film’s success and critical acclaim indicate a growing interest in the inner workings of the Catholic Church and the traditions surrounding the papal conclave.

Gabriele Regalbuto, a Senior Editor of SEO at Fox News Digital, has covered a range of breaking news events and political cycles. With a background in journalism and communications, she brings a unique perspective to her coverage of current events and cultural phenomena.