Pierre Poilievre’s record on Indigenous rights concerns advocates

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre recently made headlines for speaking to a bust of Canada’s first prime minister, John A. Macdonald, in an election ad. Poilievre expressed his admiration for Macdonald, particularly for his role in building the Canadian Pacific Railway. However, critics have pointed out that Macdonald’s legacy is marred by his treatment of Indigenous Peoples, including the displacement of communities and his support for the residential school system.

Métis lawyer Bruce McIvor has raised concerns about Poilievre’s admiration for Macdonald, suggesting that Poilievre aspires to be a 21st-century version of the former prime minister. Poilievre has referenced Macdonald in various speeches and social media posts, emphasizing the need for national projects and celebrating Macdonald’s legacy.

However, Poilievre’s record on Indigenous issues has come under scrutiny. In 2008, he made controversial comments about the residential school system, suggesting that survivors needed to adopt a better work ethic rather than receive compensation. He also voted against a bill to align Canadian laws with the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, citing concerns about free, prior, and informed consent.

During a recent visit to the Arctic, Poilievre announced plans to create a new military base in Nunavut without consulting local communities, drawing criticism from Indigenous leaders. Additionally, his campaign promises, such as pre-approving infrastructure projects like the Canadian First National Energy Corridor and granting mining permits in the Ring of Fire, have raised red flags for Indigenous advocates like McIvor.

Despite these criticisms, Poilievre’s campaign has highlighted policies like the First Nations resource charge, which aims to empower Indigenous communities to tax resource development projects on their lands. While some Indigenous leaders support this approach, concerns remain about the policy’s implementation and its impact on consultation and autonomy.

Overall, Poilievre’s stance on Indigenous issues and his admiration for figures like Macdonald have sparked debate within the Indigenous community. As the election campaign continues, Indigenous advocates will be closely watching to see how Poilievre’s promises align with the principles of reconciliation and respect for Indigenous rights.