Australia is banning social media for those under 16. Is it a solution for Canada?

Australia’s new law banning social media for those under 16 is making waves in the online safety world, with experts predicting it could influence Canadian efforts to protect young people online. While the law is being hailed as a step in the right direction, some are calling it a “sledgehammer approach” that may not be the best solution.

The law, passed on Thursday, will require social media companies like TikTok, Instagram, and Snapchat to take steps to keep users under 16 off their platforms or face fines. This move comes in the midst of lawsuits in Canada and the U.S. accusing social media companies of harming young people, as well as proposed updates to online safety legislation in various countries.

Tech analyst and journalist Carmi Levy believes that Australia’s bold move will push Canada to take action. However, he acknowledges that implementing a ban like this will come with challenges, such as age-authentication, data collection, and privacy concerns.

While the ban is seen as an imperfect solution, it underscores the growing demand for tech companies to be held accountable for the impact of their platforms on young users. Matt Hatfield, executive director of Open Media, a digital rights group, emphasizes the need for a more nuanced approach that allows young people to gradually learn about and engage with social media in a safe and age-appropriate manner.

Bree McEwan, an associate professor at the University of Toronto, warns that a blanket ban could hinder the positive aspects of social media for young people, such as connecting with peers and engaging in civic discussions. She believes that banning social media outright is too simplistic a response to the complex challenges faced by young Canadians online.

Ultimately, the debate over social media bans highlights the need for a comprehensive approach to online safety that includes not only regulation but also investment in mental health services, education, and support for young people. While Australia’s law may serve as a catalyst for change, the focus should be on creating a balanced and effective strategy to protect young people in the digital age.